Laughlin Legal official favicon

Trust Litigation

Bay Area

“A trust is often the expression of someone’s wishes for the people and things that matter most to them. When disputes arise over those wishes, the conflict can reach far beyond the assets themselves. I work with clients facing difficult questions about a loved one’s intentions, a trustee’s decisions, or whether an inheritance is being handled as it should be. These cases require more than an understanding of the law; they require a careful look at the people, relationships, and circumstances behind the dispute. My goal is to help clients understand their options, protect their interests, and pursue a resolution that honors what matters most to them.” 

Lucas Pastuszka | Trusts & Estates Senior Associate

Few people are eager to file a trust litigation lawsuit. When a dispute over a trust arises, the legal issues are often only part of the problem. Family history, old resentments, and competing expectations about an inheritance can make an already difficult situation even harder. But ask Bay Area Trusts & Estates attorney Lucas Pastuszka, what could be worse, he answers with two dreaded words: probate litigation. 

Probate litigation can bring the same family conflict and resentment as trust litigation, with the added burdens of greater expense, procedural complexity, and public scrutiny. That is one reason many Bay Area families choose a revocable living trust rather than relying on a will alone. A trust does not eliminate the possibility of a family dispute, but it can help avoid probate and the complications that may come with it.

As a Senior Associate at Laughlin Legal Family Law Group in the Bay Area, Mr. Pastuszka has seen how quickly disagreements over a trust can become personal. He also knows that not every dispute needs to end in a courtroom battle. That’s a conversation he’s had many times over the years. Sometimes, a clear-eyed outside perspective and an honest conversation about the legal issues can help families find a way forward without sacrificing relationships in the process. Below, you’ll find his answers to a number of the most common questions he fields about trust litigation in the Bay Area. 

Q      Can a Bay Area trust litigation attorney help resolve a dispute  before a trust needs to be litigated? 

LUCAS PASTUSZKA     Yes! We prefer that. Oftentimes, disputes are a matter of miscommunication, or high emotions as a result of someone in the family passing away. There are a number of options before litigation, like mediation, or arbitration if necessary. And the sooner the better. 

Litigation is always a last resort. It’s expensive, time consuming, stressful and rarely is everyone happy at the end.

Q      At what point should someone contact a Bay Area trust litigation lawyer?  

LUCAS PASTUSZKA      As soon as you suspect either a breach of fiduciary duty, financial elder abuse, bad faith by a trustee, or a potentially invalid trust document. Many situations can trigger that phone call. It really depends upon where you’re sitting.

If you are the trustee/administrator, you should, first of all, contact a trusts and estates attorney to assist you with administration to prevent any disagreements, tension, and to allow for the administration to pass through seamlessly. Do not try to administer a trust on your own. Trying to administer a trust without legal guidance can lead to delays, miscommunication, and disputes that might otherwise have been avoided. Trustees that are not informed or fail to communicate with beneficiaries, create tension and nervous beneficiaries who tend to react by getting their own attorneys in preparation for litigation. It becomes an arms race of attorneys as everyone has to lawyer up. Next thing you know, the trust is absorbed by litigation. 

If you start hearing whispers from beneficiaries that someone is disgruntled or unhappy, definitely reach out so your attorney can plan for and preempt litigation, and develop a strategy for dealing with litigation if it does happen.

So if you are or believe you are a beneficiary, a few situations should trigger a call to a trusts and estates attorney. 

One, if you did not receive a copy of a trust that you know exists. 

Two, if you’ve tried reaching out to the trustee/administrator for information, or a copy of the trust or will, and you did not receive a response, or received a negative response.

Three, if you notice that the trustee/administrator, or someone else, seems to have access to funds or is doing anything that seems improper (ex. a breach of some kind). For instance, you haven’t even received a trustee notification or a copy of the trust and you notice that the trustee is rolling around in a new orange Lamborghini, it’s not a good sign. Or perhaps you fear that someone in your family is being manipulated by the trustee. Maybe your grandfather has dementia and is suddenly signing away his orange Lamborghini. Things like this happen. And at that point you should certainly reach out to your trusts and estates attorney.

Q      How can I identify an experienced trust dispute attorney in the Bay Area? 

LUCAS PASTUSZKA     It is important to find an experienced trust dispute attorney, but even more importantly, find an attorney with integrity. Sadly, trusts and estates is a field of law where clients end up spending far more than necessary because an attorney encourages conflict, fans the flames of family tensions, or prolongs disputes that could have been resolved more efficiently. When someone you love has passed, emotions are high, people are vulnerable and more likely to be taken advantage of. Occasionally, I’ll be dealing with opposing counsel and it’s clear that an issue can be resolved easily, quickly, and less expensively. But they clearly intend to milk it to the max. 

Ideally, you’ll find someone with integrity through a referral. Ask friends and family if they know of someone you can trust.  Word of mouth is best. Then when you meet for an initial consultation with the attorney, you need to get a feel for their character. Trust your initial intuitive or gut response to an attorney who comes across as sleazy, manipulative, or something just doesn’t feel right. In that case, find someone else, because this person you choose is likely going to be around for well over a year. Choose well.

Q      Should someone pre-emptively speak with a trust contest lawyer in the Bay Area before getting married or divorced?

LUCAS PASTUSZKA      No, it’s not necessary. Unless there is a legitimate concern regarding a known conflict that might arise in the trust, or there is something you’re uncomfortable with, there’s generally no reason to specifically seek that advice.

Q      Is trust litigation in the Bay Area common? 

LUCAS PASTUSZKA      Yes, it is common, quite common in the San Francisco Bay Area. And the courts are overwhelmed to the point that sometimes we’re waiting over half a year just for a court date. Unfortunately, wherever you have a large population of high achievers with high incomes and large estates you’re more likely to attract disputes because there is something worth fighting over.

Q      Are there attorneys who specialize in breaches, like a Bay Area trustee dispute attorney or breach of trust attorney in the Bay Area?  

LUCAS PASTUSZKA      It comes with the territory. That’s not to say that handling trustee disputes is a service that all trusts and estates attorneys provide. They don’t. But while dispute and litigation attorneys will generally also do drafting, drafting attorneys often don’t do litigation and trust disputes. We’re in the former group. We like it all and do it all.

Q      Is it important to work with a dedicated Bay Area trust litigation law firm? 

LUCAS PASTUSZKA     Not necessarily. What matters most is finding an attorney with specific experience in trust litigation, whether they work at a dedicated trusts and estates firm or a firm that handles multiple practice areas. Trust litigation is a specialized niche field with its own statutes, procedures, and practical considerations. California has a separate Probate Code, probate courts, and trust disputes often involve issues that attorneys practicing primarily in family law, business litigation, criminal law, or other areas may not regularly encounter. For that reason, I would focus less on the firm’s overall practice areas and more on the individual attorney’s experience handling trust disputes. Whether the issue involves a trustee’s alleged misconduct, a challenge to a trust amendment, or a disagreement over the distribution of assets, you want an attorney who understands the nuances of California trust law and has experience navigating these disputes.

MEET OUR BAY AREA ESTATE PLANNING ATTORNEYS

PRACTICE AREAS
PRACTICE AREAS

Fast

FAQs

What types of disputes can a Bay Area trust litigation attorney handle?

A Bay Area trust litigation attorney usually handles cases that involve disputes over a trustee’s conduct, mismanagement of trust assets, beneficiary rights, interpretation of trust terms, or the validity of a trust or amendment. They can also handle allegations of financial elder abuse, fraud, undue influence, or breach of fiduciary duty.

Yes. A trust or amendment may be challenged if there is evidence that the person who created it lacked the necessary mental capacity, was subjected to undue influence, or was otherwise improperly induced to sign it.

A trustee may breach their duties by misappropriating trust assets, engaging in self-dealing, failing to properly manage investments, favoring certain beneficiaries, or failing to follow the terms of the trust. Failing to communicate with beneficiaries or provide required information and accountings can also create legal problems.

Beneficiaries may have the right to demand information and an accounting, and can petition the probate court to compel the trustee to fulfill those obligations. Depending on the circumstances, they may also seek the trustee’s removal or other relief for a breach of trust.

Trust litigation generally takes place generally in the probate division of the California Superior Court, and may involve petitions, discovery, evidentiary hearings, and sometimes trial. These proceedings can be expensive and time-consuming, which is why we encourage exploring resolution through communication or mediation, before resorting to litigation, whenever possible.

Terminology

A legal arrangement in which a person or entity (the trustee) holds and manages property for the benefit of one or more beneficiaries, according to the terms of the trust.

A legal dispute involving the creation, validity, interpretation, administration, or distribution of a trust. Trust litigation may involve disagreements over a trustee’s conduct, a beneficiary’s rights, the validity of a trust or amendment, or the proper distribution of trust assets.

A person or entity entitled to receive benefits from a trust, which may include income, distributions of property, or other benefits provided under the trust’s terms. 

A trustee is the person or entity responsible for holding, managing, and administering trust assets in accordance with the trust’s terms and applicable law. A trustee is often a spouse, domestic partner, family member, or professional fiduciary. The term “trust administrator” is sometimes used informally to describe someone handling trust administration, but it is not necessarily a separate legal role from that of a trustee.

Case Story

A trust litigator on
how it’s rarely just about
money or property.

“In the summer of 2015, while serving as a Judicial Law Clerk with the Superior Court of California, County of San Francisco, I was involved In the Matter of the Robin Williams Trust (Case No. PTR-14-298367), the highly publicized probate proceedings concerning the estate of Robin Williams. Following his death in 2014, a dispute arose between his widow, Susan Schneider Williams, and his three adult children over the interpretation of his trust and the distribution of personal belongings, including watches, bicycles, clothing, photographs, and memorabilia. What might have seemed like a dispute over possessions was, in reality, a deeply personal conflict over the wishes and legacy of a husband and father.

By the summer of 2015, the dispute had grown to involve hundreds of personal items, along with disagreements concerning the Tiburon home Susan had shared with Robin. His children sought to enforce their understanding of his estate plan, while Susan sought clarification about what the trust provided for her and which belongings were intended for the children. The proceedings illustrated how even a carefully prepared estate plan can lead to conflict when its terms are interpreted differently by the people left behind.

The family ultimately reached a settlement in September 2015, avoiding a final judicial determination of the disputed issues. Having witnessed this case firsthand, I was reminded that probate is rarely just about money or property. It is often about grief, family relationships, and the meaning attached to a lifetime of memories. Clear estate planning can help prevent these disputes, but sometimes the greatest challenge is helping families navigate the emotional weight of carrying out a loved one’s wishes.”

in our opinion

Next Step

Book a consultation.

Have a conversation with a member of our Bay Area Trusts & Estates team to talk about your trust case.

If you’re looking for great advice on trusts and trust litigation, let’s talk. Call us at 650.343.3486 or email us here.

Let’s get started.

The FOREFRONT A divorce & family law blog

Trusts are on the rise in California. Given the concentration of wealth in various areas of the state, there is no shortage of

As an estate planning attorney working for a family law office and practicing estate planning law here in San Mateo, Santa Clara, San

Estate planning plays a vital role in financial planning, particularly when you want to control how others handle your assets after your passing.

You have rights.

Let’s talk about your options.

Schedule a consultation with one of our lawyers.

By providing a telephone number and submitting this form, you are consenting to be contacted by SMS text message. Message & data rates may apply. Message frequency may vary. Privacy Policy Reply HELP for more information. You can reply STOP to opt out of further messaging.

LAUGHLIN LEGAL Divorce & Family Law Group   650.343.3486   info@LaughlinLegal.com
Hablamos espanol | Mowimy po polsku | Мы говорим по-русски

“I got my son back! She negotiated nothing short of a miracle.”
“Really high integrity, really high advocacy”
“I knew she was going to kill it in court. And she did.”
“GREAT thought partners."
“They're like freedom fighters ."
Want to feel confident
about your future?

LAUGHLIN LEGAL Divorce & Family Law Group | You’ve never been better protected.
Serving clients in San Mateo, Santa Clara, San Francisco, Alameda & Contra Costa counties, as well as across the country and around the world.